Highgarden Real Estate
REALTOR ®
(317) 509-9406
Email Betsy
mobile navigation links

5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254

PENDING as of 6/4/2025 - $204,900
Charming townhouse with a brick facade and attached two-car garage, plus well-maintained landscaping at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254

  • Bedrooms

    2

  • Baths

    3

  • Sq. Feet

    1646

  • Year Built

    1988

  • Days on Market

    8

  • $/SqFt

    $124

Message Agent
Schedule Tour

53 Photos

  • Charming townhouse with a brick facade and attached two-car garage, plus well-maintained landscaping at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Exterior view of the house showing the concrete driveway, green lawn, and landscaping at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Exterior view of townhouses showing the garages, driveways, lawns, and proximity to the pond at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • View of home's exterior displaying the front door, brickwork, siding, and well-kept lawn at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • View of front porch showcasing the red storm door, brick columns, and pot of colorful flowers at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Inviting foyer featuring tile flooring, decorative door, and interior door at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Open concept living room with fireplace, ceiling fan, dining table, and bar area at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Half bathroom with vanity sink, neutral paint, towel ring, and baseboards at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Half bathroom featuring a black vanity, chrome fixtures, and vanity lighting at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Spacious living room featuring a fireplace, fan, dining area, and bar area at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy living room featuring a fireplace, plush seating, and modern decor at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Inviting living space with a staircase, television, and comfortable seating at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Close-up of the fireplace featuring a wooden mantel and decorative screen at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Open-concept living room with a view of the kitchen and staircase at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright home office space with natural light and a view of the pond at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Dining area with open access to the kitchen and bright lighting at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy dining area adjacent to an open-concept kitchen, and a large window at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Well-lit dining area, adjacent to a living area with pond views and a fireplace at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Open living space featuring dining, living, and office areas at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright kitchen with white cabinets, modern appliances, and tile flooring at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright kitchen features white cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and a convenient center island for added workspace at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
More Photos \/
  • Modern kitchen showcases stainless steel refrigerator, island, and open layout connecting to the living area at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Close-up of modern stainless steel appliances, including a microwave and oven, set against a tiled backsplash at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Kitchen features double sink, tile backsplash, and plenty of counter space for meal preparation at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Spacious kitchen features stainless steel refrigerator and easy access to the backdoor at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Functional laundry room features a side-by-side washer and dryer and ample overhead cabinet space at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Upstairs hallway showcases wooden banister and leads to a carpeted bedroom at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Well-lit hallway offers an open view into the Bedroom at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy bedroom features vaulted ceilings, carpet flooring, and a neutral color scheme at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright bedroom with skylight, vaulted ceilings, and ample closet space at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright, neutral bedroom featuring a queen bed, ceiling fan, and a large window with natural light at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • A serene lake view from a private wooden balcony, with trees and greenery in the background at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • A wooden balcony overlooking a tranquil lake, with a satellite dish and trees in the background at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Scenic view of a lake from a wooden balcony with lush greenery and trees surrounding the water at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Well-lit bathroom featuring a tiled floor, a bathtub, and a vanity with a sink at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright bathroom with a white countertop, wooden cabinets, and a view into the main bedroom at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Corner bathtub with a tiled surround and a chrome faucet set against neutral walls at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Corner bathtub and commode with tile and wainscoting accents at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Well-lit Bedroom with a canopy crib, dresser, and daybed at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright, airy bedroom with a canopy crib and twin bed with neutral color walls at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bright bedroom featuring a white dresser with mirror and a window with sheer curtains at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy bedroom featuring a crib with sheer canopy, comfortable bed, and ceiling fan at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy bedroom with a white-framed bed, vaulted ceiling, and neutral color palette at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Clean bathroom with glass-enclosed shower, wood vanity, and a well-lit mirror at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Bathroom featuring a sink, vanity, mirror, and access to other rooms at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Spacious backyard with green lawn, patio seating, and serene lake view at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Back exterior view of the home, with a patio, green lawn, and lake views at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Well-maintained backyard with lush lawn, towering evergreens, and patio area at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Sprawling backyard with meticulously mowed lawn, mature trees, and inviting patio at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Cozy outdoor patio with seating area perfect for enjoying the serene backyard at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Outdoor patio with seating, grill, and view of the lake in a serene setting at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • An outdoor patio featuring seating, a grill, and access to the home's exterior at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
  • Patio seating offering peaceful views of a pond and community green space at 5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Less Photos /\

Tour This Home

Fri
6 Jun
Sat
7 Jun
Sun
8 Jun
Mon
9 Jun
Tue
10 Jun
Wed
11 Jun
Thu
12 Jun
Schedule Tour

Home Description

Welcome to this beautiful two-story condo offering peaceful pond views and a quiet, serene atmosphere. The spacious kitchen features a center island, breakfast bar, updated cabinets and a walk-in pantry! The open floor plan creates the perfect space for entertaining or everyday living. Cozy up to your fireplace in the living room or step out onto your private back porch to enjoy a cup of coffee while overlooking the beautiful scenery. Upstairs, the spacious primary bedroom features vaulted ceilings, a skylight, a private balcony and an ensuite bath with a garden tub. The second bedroom offers abundant natural light, a walk-in closet and an adjoining full bathroom, perfect for guests or a home office. Enjoy the pool or tennis courts or take a quick drive to Eagle Park for some outdoor fun hiking, kayaking or a picnic. Close to shopping, interstate access and restaurants, this condo has it all! Schedule your showing today!

  • MLS #: 22038206
  • Street Address: 5372 Bay Harbor Dr
  • City: Indianapolis
  • Zip: 46254
  • County: Marion
  • Township: Pike
  • Subdivision: Hidden Bay
  • Property Type: Condo / Townhouse
  • Style: TraditonalAmerican
  • Garage Spaces: 2
  • Acres: <1/4 Acre
  • Lot Description: Corner Lot,Mature Trees,Sidewalks,Street Lights
  • Siding: Vinyl With Brick
  • Patio & Porch: Covered Patio,Deck UP
  • Fencing: Privacy

Approximate Room Sizes / Descriptions

Great Room26x19Main
Dining Room11x11Main
Kitchen13x11Main
Laundry6x3Main
Primary Bedroom20x13Upper
Bedroom 217x13Upper
  • Interior Description: Attic Pull Down Stairs,Breakfast Bar,Center Island,Entrance Foyer,Pantry,Screens Complete,Skylight(s),Supplemental Storage,Vaulted Ceiling(s),Walk-in Closet(s),Windows Thermal,Wood Work Stained
  • Full Baths: 2
  • Half Baths: 1
  • Num Fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace Description: Great Room,Woodburning Fireplce
  • Primary Bedroom Description: Balcony,Closet Walk in
  • Appliances: Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Electric Oven,Electric Water Heater,MicroHood,Refrigerator,Washer
  • Eating Area: Dining Combo/Family Room
  • Equipment: Smoke Alarm
  • Heating: Heat Pump
  • : lmyers@highgarden.com

Neighborhood

The average asking price of a 2 bedroom Indianapolis home in this zip code is $182,500 (10.9% less than this home).

This home is priced at $124/sqft, which is 30.8% less than similar homes in the 46254 zip code.

Map | Street | Birds Eye

Print Map | Driving Directions

School Information

  • School District:MSD Pike Township

Financial

  • Approx Payment:$1,018*
  • Semi Annual Taxes:$786

Area Stats

These statistics are updated daily from the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service. For further analysis or to obtain statistics not shown below please call Highgarden Real Estate at (317) 509-9406 and speak with one of our real estate consultants.

Popular Homes

City
Avg Price
Median Price
Available
Distressed
Reduced
Avg DOM
Broad Ripple
$480,055
$377,450
22
0.0%
36.4%
47

Butler Tarkington
$351,318
$345,000
17
0.0%
52.9%
137

Downtown Indianapolis
$342,927
$244,950
30
0.0%
70.0%
285

Fountain Square
$344,861
$341,000
36
0.0%
55.6%
58

Irvington
$261,263
$212,000
83
0.0%
55.4%
80

Meridian Kessler
$597,446
$474,900
45
0.0%
51.1%
46

Listing Courtesy of Highgarden Real Estate.

5372 Bay Harbor Dr, Indianapolis IN is a single family home of 1646 sqft and is currently priced at $204,900 . This single family home has 2 bedrooms. In addition to single family homes, Highgarden also makes it easy to find Homes, Condos, New Homes and Foreclosures in Indianapolis, IN. Arbor Village, Eagle Cove and Eagles Knoll are nearby neighborhoods. MLS 22038206 has been posted on this site since 5/29/2025 (today).

2025

Message Agent

Send

Schedule a tour

5372 Bay Harbor Dr Indianapolis IN 46254

Choose a day and time

You Requested

We'll be in touch shortly to confirm your tour time and other details. Please let us know how to reach you.

Schedule Tour

CLOSE

Your message has been sent!

The agent will be in touch with you in just a minute.